« Clinton at Aspen | Main | Mobile Phones for Development »

Mapping Politics

iraqfatalitymap.jpgMaps are not neutral -- or, rather, the creation of maps is not a neutral process. The choice of what the map covers, and what details to include or exclude, is an inherently subjective process. We saw an example of that recently in the Chicago Crime Map, in which all offenses looked the same, and the data only covered arrests, not convictions (i.e., whether a crime has actually been committed remains legally in doubt). (Update: the very first comment below is from Chicago Crime Map, telling us that they added a color difference between different crime types shortly after I first took a look at them. Thanks!) Another example comes to us from Future Feeder, one that is extremely well-presented yet invites bigger questions about objectivity and information.

The Iraq War Fatalities map is a Flash-based display of Coalition deaths over the course of the conflict, up to June 27, 2005. The fatalities are shown as small dots on the map reflecting their location, and are listed day-by-day; sound and color are used to represent how many died on a given day (I highly recommend running the map with sound on). It's a simple display, but quite powerful.

The map is arguably very informative, in that it makes it easy to get a sense of the patterns of violence over the course of the war. For example, it lets users see: where the conflict is ongoing, and where it is sporadic; where there are cycles matching the months or seasons; and to what degree the conflict is localized, and to what degree it is spread throughout the country. The Iraq War Fatality map is an impressive presentation of the war's spatial, temporal and level-of-violence characteristics; it's a format that could apply well beyond this particular case. One could imagine using the method for the display of car accidents, customer service calls, or any other set of information where the location and intensity vary over time.

But it's impossible to escape the political aspect of the map. Causes of death are not distinguished, and neither does it include listings of objectives achieved -- a useful piece of data, in particular, for measuring against the rising and falling patterns of violence. Similarly, the number of Iraqi deaths is missing; the makers of the map originally wanted to include them, but found that they could not get reliable numbers. But by not listing Iraqi deaths -- whether civilian, government or guerilla-- the focus becomes entirely on the costs to Coalition forces, particularly the US.

The Iraq War Fatality map is simultaneously a terrific example of how multiple categories of data can be displayed via mapping and how hard it is to present complex sets of information completely.


Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Mapping Politics:

» Déformation involontaire from Le Chialeux de Salon
L’information n’est pas neutre, je le sais, vous le savez, tout le monde le sait, mais l’a toujours en tête? Ainsi pour faire d’une pierre deux coups je vous présente une vision de l’avenir de l’information sur internet (et peut-être ... [Read More]

Comments (3)

All offenses on chicagocrime.org do not look the same. The map markers are colored differently depending on the category of crime. See http://www.chicagocrime.org/about/maps/ for more information.

I get that categorization directly from the Chicago Police Department, which uses the same categories on its own Web site.

That feature was added a week or so after the site launched, so maybe you didn't see the change.

Thanks for this, Adrian. You're right -- that came after I checked out the site. I will add a note in the text.

As Jamais points out, maps are a really powerful way to convey an interpretation of the world around us. It will be interesting to see what people do with the huge volume of digital images now available.

There are some great low-tech versions of this as well. One of my favourite map artists is Ingo Günther [http://worldprocessor.com/index_vis.htm]who re-shapes standard globes to make some startling braincandy.

I've posted links to that and some other map related sites at www.doublefiltered.squarespace.com.

I'd love to see links to other peoples' favourites.


This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on July 10, 2005 2:03 PM.

The previous post in this blog was Clinton at Aspen.

The next post in this blog is Mobile Phones for Development.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Powered by
Movable Type 3.34